St. Louis, United States
Here’s the honest take. Their own domain performance isn’t giving you much hard SEO proof to work with, but you do see solid client satisfaction, which usually doesn’t happen if an agency is totally clueless. That tells me they can likely deliver a decent experience and some results, even if their own site isn’t screaming “SEO powerhouse” on its face. Would I hire them purely as an SEO consulting partner? I’d be cautious and ask them to walk you through specific client wins and rankings, since their own domain isn’t clearly doing the selling for them. If they can show you real case studies and a clear process to back up that satisfaction, they might be worth a shot, but I wouldn’t rely on their site alone as proof of top-tier SEO skills.
Looking for an SEO agency? Before you lock yourself into a pricey retainer, let AISEOMate do the heavy lifting for a fraction of the cost. We crawl your site and competitors in depth, uncover the full topic cluster map for your niche, and spin up long-form, ready to publish articles that drive real organic traffic.